profile | register | search
|
|
profile | register | search |
| Forums | Kashrus | Waiting six hours | Post Reply | Send Topic To a Friend |
| Author | Topic |
| Punims | Posted - 03 June 2002 0:04
If your minhag changes to a 'lower' standard -- do you still switch? For example - marrying someone who doesn't keep cholov Yisroel when you do. Or marrying someone who waits 3 hours when you're used to waiting 6. |
| MODERATOR | Posted - 03 June 2002 1:52
Cholov Yisroel is not a Minhag. It a Hlachah that, at least l'chatchilah, everyone must keep, even according to Rav Moshe. It is not subject to the laws of Minhagim. |
| Punims | Posted - 10 June 2002 5:30
Hmmm... I didn't know that. What bout going down to 3 hours? |
| MODERATOR | Posted - 10 June 2002 6:08
Thats a legitimate Minhag, but only for those who really have the Minhag. |
| hamikdash3 | Posted - 28 May 2004 20:36
There is a machlokes rishonim in interpreting the gemorra in Chullin 105a I don't eat it (milchigs) in this meal, but in another meal I do. Rambam holds that it means c'dei shiur s'uda acheres v'hu cmo sheish sha'os. Tosaphos holds that it is sheim s'uda acheres, and all one needs to do is bentch and clean out his mouth. If the Rambam had meant 5 hours and a minute (i.e. into the sixth hour) he would have written c'mo chamesh sha'os. I asked rabbi Bresslaue (a"h) of Washington Heights why the Yekkes wait three hours, he said because in Germany they had a s'eudah every three hours. But the one hour minhag is not based on the Rambam, but rather Tosaphos. The Rama in Yoreh De'ah 87:1 brings Tosaphos's opinion that you don't have to wait any particular time (bentch and wash mouth) and then says that the minhag is to wait an hour. The G'ra there says that this is based on the Zohar. |
Click Here To Close Thread, Administrators & Moderators Only.
Show All Forums |
Post Reply